Ive had food here twice. Everything that was cooked was at best mediocre- usually worse than that. My food was cooked in old grease so it had that flavor.
That said, go to the hotel, but go expecting a very basic facility. Cedar Island is one of the quietest, most peaceful places I know. If you are into a place that has beaitiful empty beaches with horses on it sometimes, where the only sounds you hear after the last ferry is that of the winds, bugs, and birds then this is the place for you. It can be an extremely relaxing experience.
Just get your food at the other place and expect a basic hotel.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.