We needed to pick up lunch close to our motel and we stopped in here. I had read some reviews here but still was on a time/location crunch so Oak Island Restaurant it was. There were numerous elderly customers there and my wife pointed out that was likely a good sign of a decent local eating establishment.
We had a decent peaceful meal but I regret ordering the Flounder/Shrimp meal. The flounder had a disclaimer "may contain bones" that I wrongly assumed was a simple disclaimer for filets. No-they were heavily boned flounder that was NOT flavorful ("we are known for our flounder" an employee had told us...)
The server did a good job (I regret that I can't recall her name) and I would go back but not for the flounder. My thoughts on this restaurant for tourists is use it for lunch to avoid the overflowing parking lots at the higher rated places and stick to basic fares on the menu.