Stopped by the Newcastle Inn without knowing what to expect at all. It was not a mistake. It's the best meal I've had in a restaurant in years. Everything is made from scratch. Homemade as homemade can get. 3 of us had the pan fried Haddock. It was light and tasty. Mashed potatoes were made fresh and the vegetables were cooked to perfection. Not frozen nor preheated and recooked. My husband had liver & onions with rice and again, everything was cooked to perfection and nothing was frozen reheated foods. The service was impecable. The food was just like you'd make it at home. Doesn't come more homemade than that. My husband had a greek salad and thought it was one of the best. Yes, a "real" Greek salad may not have lettuce but some do and some people like it that way. It was not loaded with lettuce, just enough to give it a nice color and crunch and he loved the vinaigrette. If you don't want lettuce, ask if it's possible to have it without. It's as simple as that. Would we go again, oh yeah! We're 1hr away and plan on going quite a few times to try different meals.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.