well let me add to list of diners who left unhappy. I have to say that the wait staff were trying to please but the meal!!!
I left telling others reading the posted menu to walk on by because we just had one of the worst meals ever! The only saving grace was the beer..it came out of a bottle thank goodness.
My liver was like eating glue...lots of flour coating unseared yet overcooked...like it was steamed.
Still can`t get that taste out of my mouth.
My husband had fish and chips. Fresh perch. How can you go wrong?
It was heavily floured and clearly the oil was not hot enough to make it crispy so it was doughy.
The fries were the most disgusting...limp and extremely greasy.
What a disappointment after driving an hour and a half for a meal.
We sailed out of Bayfield Marina for several years past and the Red Pump was THE place to go for that special (expensive) meal. What the heck happened? Same owner cause I saw him wandering around.
I guess it is old and tired like I am...past its best before date!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.