One of the best things about Kelley's Island is that there are no food chain restaurants there - whatever you eat comes directly from owners who cook and serve it. The best place to buy pizza on the island is Caddy Shack - nice that's it's also the most reasonably priced. You get just what you want on it and it comes to your table in 20 minutes. If you don't like the bare bones atmosphere of the large dining area or bar, take your pizza out to the town square and eat it on a picnic table facing Lake Erie.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.