I almost hate to review this restaurant, because I wouldn't want it to be crowded next time I'm in town. But, they do such an amazing job, they deserve the raves. OUTSTANDING!
I ordered the roast beef and my friend ordered the chicken and corn pot pie. Everything is made from scratch and delicious. We both had "potato filling" as a side. It is one of the best things I have ever had in my life. It's as if mashed potatoes were crossed with stuffing (or "filling" as it's called in PA). The resulting food would be this heavenly dish of creamy, seasoned mashed potatoes, baked to a golden color. Unbelievable.
Although we did not order oyster stew, we saw others ordering it. Each one is prepared to order in the kitchen. Then the chef brings a saucepan to the table, and ladles out the oyster stew into a wide soup bowl. It looked divine.
We have eaten at many places in the area, and this is far and away the best. We will return every time we visit Lancaster Co. In fact, although we had lunch there today, we are going back for dinner tonight. This will be my last chance for potato filling for many months!
Sadly for us, they are closed on Sundays, like most places in the area. Also, be aware that they only take cash, so come prepared. The food is so good, you won't mind a trip to the ATM beforehand.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.