There is no option for giving a 2-1/2 star review, so moved it up to average as we didn't have the burgers or steaks which many of your reviewers say were very good. Once we parked our luggage at a local B&B, we headed into town for a light supper (nothing fancy, just a few appetizers or light fare). My itinerary included Mosby's Pub based on it's very good reviews. We were not impressed. Maybe this was an off-night, but first impressions are crucial to repeat business. The selection of appetizers was more of a fried-foods frenzy. My friend and I had 2 small average salads (how can you ruin a salad?), 12 wings (hot spicy oil on the bottom, waitress didn't ask us what type of wings & sauce) and a decent blue cheese french bread. We paid extra for blue cheese and celery. My daughter had a cream of potato soup which she thought came from a can (probably didn't, but...) and shared with us her over-fried cauliflower. The wings tasted like wings from many other good places, but we didn't know they had other flavors llike garlic. The problem is the waitress we had. Perhaps she was new, perhaps not. She didn't ask what type of wings we wanted, nor did she supply us with a sauce for the fried cauliflower although we asked numerous times. Service was very slow and we felt we were dealing with a dim-wit. Sorry, but poor waitstaff reflects badly on even the best restaurants. We asked for some garlic sauce for the wings and she gave us garlic chips. This went on for a bit until we slowly reiterated our request for a side of garlic wing SAUCE (which was good, by the way). The place itself could use the services of a Restaurant Impossible just in decor alone. Looked like a run-down VFW hall. Maybe the burgers and steaks are good (and we're willing to try one more time should we be in the Mt. Joy area again), but our fried appetizers and small fare were not pleasing to the palate. However, the french bread with blue cheese was yummy and my travel mates did love the pumpkin beer.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.