I used to pass Joe's on the way to school every day and eventually curiosity got the better of me sometime in 1996. On a Friday night I went and ordered a slice of pizza, mozzarella sticks, and a vanilla shake. They were fantastic. I visited on a regular basis the entire time I lived in this city and still go back to visit it when I am in town.
13 years later and the food is the EXACT SAME. So many places change their food when there's nothing wrong with it (usually to cut costs). I do remember once they changed to a cheaper mozzarella stick but when people did not like them (and when the staff did not like them) they changed back.
If you are a fan of great food, great shakes, and great Italian Ice this is the place for you.
The downsides? It's cramped inside (as it is the bottom floor of a house), the staff can get a bit loud, and the location isn't in the nicest area on earth. But if you want great food there's really nothing else in York that can top it.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.