My husband and I have been to Mi Casa a handful of times since moving here four years ago. A couple years ago, they updated their menu and refined some things. They have very good Mexican food and great margaritas. This is a lively, fun place at night, with the college being so close in Sewanee. The prices are good and the portions are generous. Out of any place to eat on the mountain (Monteagle) this is the best stop. If you're traveling and happen to exit in Monteagle, take a left and keep going until you're almost out of town. Just a couple miles. It will be on your left. Skip everything else in town. You will be happy you did.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.