Based on the reviews here we decided to give the Stillwater Inn a try for our anniversary dinner and I must say the reviews were spot on! We made reservations for Saturday night but decided to go early instead (had a ghost tour to attend) and it seems that reservations weren't necessary. We were immediately greeted and seated in a cozy room with bird themed art (how did they know?!?) and the waiter was prompt to attend to our drinks and appetizers. Our dinners (both fish) were perfection itself and the service constant without being a nuisance. This is the perfect place for any special occasion or when you have a hankering for fine dining. We WILL be back!