We have been coming to Smuggs for years, both summer and winter. We used to dine at the Hearth and Candle a lot and really enjoyed going there. Not anymore. The last few times we have been disappointed by the food, service, and price. We don't mind paying for good food if we truly get good food, but the Hearth and Candle seems to want to charge for great meals when in fact they are not. The whole family has agreed that we won't be going back when we can eat at Stella Notte, The Family Table, 158 Main etc and those establishments truly have great food and wonderful service. And for that matter, the locals pub just outside the resort, Brewster River, may lack ambiance, but the food is wonderful. The Hearth and Candle seems to be relying on its location in the resort to get people in the door, but has forgotten that they should be trying to get repeat customers. When we go to Smuggs we eat out every night. If we enjoyed our meals there they could have a customer for 7 nights, instead we now take our business elsewhere! Such a shame!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.