Having grown up in Sheboygan, I was convinced Faye's was the only pizza to eat. Last night a friend mentioned that the pizza at Faye's was little light on the cheese. I protested out of loyalty but.. tonight I went and checked it out for myself. We ordered a 15 inch pizza and at least 6 of the pieces had no cheese on them at all. I couldn't believe my eyes. It still was a tasty pizza but there was definitely a shortage of cheese! Very disappointing . You may want to order extra cheese to make it taste like "the old days"
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.