A long time Sheboygan resident here and many locals look at the reviews here and are more than a bit skeptical. The frozen custard is certainly good. And the old fashioned drive in with car hops is terribly quaint. BUT! BUT!! BUT!!! There are numerous places in Sheboygan and throughout Wisconsin that serve great frozen custard and ice cream. If you hang your hat on that alone you will not do well. Burgers are Gilly's are small and near tasteless unless one doctors them up with an abundance of condiments for a taste of ketchup, mustard and pickles. Cute names do NOT equate to tasty food. Drive by on any summer Saturday or Sunday -- prime time for this kind of food and you will see only a handful of cars in their lot. The honeymoon with this restaurant was over just weeks after opening!!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.