Our summer place is about 20 miles away from Frogg's, but it seems as though we always wind up finding a reason to drive there for custard. I say "custard" because this is authentic Wisconsin frozen custard--a different animal than mere "ice cream." It's much creamier and smoother than ice cream, but not as sloppy as soft serve like you'd get at DQ or McDonald's. Think carefully before ordering something bigger than a "small" because their portion sizes are LARGE! A "small" cone contains at least a 4" tall mound of custard. If you want to be good, just ask for a "tadpole" cone or dish. More than enough to satisfy the craving. It's a small little roadside place that we love visiting year after year.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.