We were in Sister bay this weekend and tried the Creamery for lunch .We knew they had great gelato but never had a mean there. My wife and ordered Meat and cheese sampler. It consisted of about 6 different lunch meats, six different cheeses, two types of bread, and some garnishes. It was great, we lived it, and can't wait to go back. The price was about $22 and my wife and I could not eat all. I would say it would feed three people comfortably.
The people working there were very nice. The service was a little slow, but worth it.