As others have suggested, this Odana Road strip mall restaurant is not where you'd expect a very good restaurant (it's only a few doors from Pizza Pit). It's higher end than expected and higher quality food than expected. The portion sizes are also more modest than many Mexican restaurants that try to make up in volume what they lack in quality - in La Mestiza the quality comes through in modest (but sufficient) portions. Carnitas (a special) was very tasty with welcome wedges of lime provided, a ball of seasoned rice, etc. Quesadilla with steak (an appetizer eaten as a meal) was excellent. Service friendly, professional and efficient. This place can get quite busy - we've passed it before when full - now we know why. Among the best Mexican in Madison's west side.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.