I recently saw Romeo and Juliet and had a wonderful time. The theater is very intimate. I arrived earlier enough on a Thursday night (about 1.5 h before curtain) and got a front row, center table. I had plenty of time to eat before the show. Dinner was good (vegetarian strata).
The play was the highlight. The company makes the performance very personal and intimate. They perform "knowing" the crowd is there, often coming out into the aisles.
If I lived in Atlanta, I would go back.