I was surprised by how great the food here was. Try to sit outside as it's a little steamy inside, and the terrace of the resort is very peaceful.
I kid you not, this meal was better than Mama's Fish House (where I've been twice). If you're in Maui, everyone will tell you to go there and, if you have time, you should do both. But just know that the food here is arguably better (even if the ambiance isn't as classic as Mama's).