I went to Pepper's in August, 2013 and it was a wonderful experience. I didn't eat any food because I'd just eaten at the resort, I only went there to meet some local friends. Anyway, the setup was really nice and comfortable, and the staff was very attentive. They kept bringing over fresh cold water and shockingly they didn't hassle us about not ordering anything.
My friend sat at the bar and had drinks which she said was reasonably priced.
Sorry I couldn't review the food, but the atmosphere was very pleasant. Will be going back and trying the food