I rented this property with 6 friends and were all slightly nervous at it was the first time we'd done this. We found the place to be slightly tired in some areas with bathrooms and kitchen appliances a little dated and in need of a freshen up, but certainly no biggy. The rooms were spacious, the living area really nice and large, with bifold doors onto the terrace. The pool was cold but once you were in it was lovely. We had a few minor maintenance issues and the property management company were very quick to resolve (although we did have issues with bed slats collapsing two nights in a row!) But they did sort it out and communication was, at all times, excellent.
The one major downside I felt was the inability to really use the beautiful large garden and the volleyball court, as the place was littered with feral cat mess (as the whole island seems to have a disgusting feral cat issue). I would have suggested putting something like Lionsroar or a similar product down to repel them from the garden, because we really didn't feel comfortable with the smell and the disgusting mess. But its an issue around the area.
That aside the place was perfect for us to attend a beach event on Trinity beach and walk into town (about 20 mins walk). Its nice and quiet, away from the busy town, but close enough to wonder in. Supermarkets are close by, as too are many bars and restaurants (5-10 mins walk).