According to forum posts, Lahaina offers a variety of Luau experiences. Some travelers recommended the Old Lahaina Luau for its traditional approach and scenic setting. Others preferred the Feast at Lele for its food quality, describing it as a Polynesian revue rather than a traditional luau. Drums of the Pacific at the Hyatt was also mentioned as a good option, especially for families with teenagers due to its inclusion of fire dancers and a diverse menu.

Travelers have noted that it's essential to book these experiences well in advance due to their popularity. Discounts may be available through direct booking, as mentioned by a user who suggested contacting the Royal Lahaina Luau directly to inquire about a direct booking discount.

The quality and type of experience vary between the luaus. Feast at Lele was repeatedly praised for its food, while the Old Lahaina Luau was highlighted for offering a more authentic cultural experience. Drums of the Pacific was suggested for those seeking a luau with vibrant performances including fire dancers.

According to forum posts, the Sheraton Maui is highly recommended for its great beach, nice pool area, and proximity to Whalers Village, which offers restaurants and shopping. Travelers have called out its location on the walkway near Whalers Village and a wider section of the beach, enhancing its appeal.

For many users, the Westin Nanea also comes highly recommended, especially for those interested in snorkeling and boogie boarding, as it is near Kahekili Beach Park, which is known for excellent snorkeling. The Royal Lahaina Resort is noted for its nice beach just north of Black Rock, offering broad fine sand and a more personal, relaxed experience.

Some travelers suggested considering condo resorts like the Honua Kai for more spacious accommodation options and amenities like kitchens, which can be a more economical choice in Lahaina. These are appreciated for offering a balance between resort amenities and the comforts of a more home-like environment.

According to forum posts, several whale watching tours are available in Lahaina. Travelers have recommended companies like Trilogy, Hawaii Ocean Project, and Gemini for their stable and large catamarans, which are suitable for those with shaky sea legs. These tours typically depart from Lahaina Harbor or Kaanapali Beach.

Some users have highlighted the importance of choosing the right type of boat for a better experience. The Kaulana by Hawaiian Ocean Project is favored for its size and stability, but travelers are advised to avoid The Maui Princess due to its layout that restricts views.

For a more intimate experience, some travelers suggest opting for tours that include fewer passengers, like those offered by smaller rafting companies. These tours are praised for providing a more personal whale watching experience, which can be particularly rewarding.