We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Melissa G's Shelter Island, NY, USA
9
Contributions
7 Reviews |
2 Ratings
Grid View
List View
Back to top
Shelter Island Whale's Tale
3 Ram Island Road
4 of 5 stars
Posted 19 Oct 2014
Mashomack Preserve
79 S. Ferry Rd.
4 of 5 stars
Posted 19 Oct 2014
Sunset Beach
35 Shore Road
3 of 5 stars
Posted 5 Sep 2013
Sunset Beach, located on the end of Crescent Beach on Shelter Island, has great scenery, views, and ...
The Pridwin Restaurant
81 Shore Road
5 of 5 stars
Posted 3 Sep 2013
Stayed at the Pridwin for a long weekend and ate several times at the restaurant. Food is good, but ...
Marie Eiffel Market
184 North Ferry Road
4 of 5 stars
Posted 1 Sep 2013
Reddings is a great resource on Shelter Island. Great food for beach or picnic. Fried chicken is exc...
The Tavern at Shelter Island House
11 Stearns Point Road
4 of 5 stars
Posted 1 Sep 2013
Great food, good service and lovely setting. We ate outside in back garden but inside room and bar a...
The Pridwin Hotel
81 Shore Road
4 of 5 stars
Posted 1 Sep 2013
Had a great weekend at the Pridwin. Classic old school elegance, great location and good service. Ro...
Clark's Fish House - CLOSED
3 North Ferry Road
5 of 5 stars
Posted 22 Aug 2013
Food was great. Food was fresh and selection was great. Great shrimp cocktail. Wonderful tomato sala...
Vine Street Cafe
41 S Ferry Rd
5 of 5 stars
Posted 22 Aug 2013
Had a wonderful meal there on a Saturday night in August. Food was fresh, selection was great and se...